How to respond to lowball offers (without losing your cool)
If you resell anything, you've seen it: you list a jacket for $60 and within minutes someone offers $10, "cash today." Lowball offers are part of the game, and the sellers who do best treat them calmly, like a puzzle rather than an insult. This guide covers how to set your floor before anyone messages, friendly scripts you can copy, and when it's smarter to just let a buyer go.
Step 1: Decide your floor before you list
The easiest way to handle any offer is to already know the lowest price you'll accept. Base it on sold comps, not active listings, then subtract fees and shipping to see what you'd actually keep. Our free resale profit calculator shows your net for eBay, Poshmark, Mercari and Depop in seconds. Write the floor in your notes. When an offer comes in, you're not deciding under pressure; you're just comparing two numbers.
Step 2: Sort the offer
- Reasonable (within about 20 to 30 percent of asking): counter with a specific number.
- Low but interested: counter once near your floor and explain the value briefly.
- Way too low (a third of the price or less): a short polite no, or no reply at all.
Copy-ready scripts
Friendly counter: "Thanks for the offer! I can't go that low, but I could do $52 for pickup today. Let me know if that works."
Counter with value: "Thanks for your interest! Similar ones in this condition have been selling for around $60, so the lowest I can do is $54."
Bundle nudge: "I can't drop this one that far, but if you add another item from my listings, I can do both for $70."
"What's your lowest?" "I'm open to reasonable offers. What did you have in mind?"
Firm price: "Thanks! The price is firm for now, but I'm happy to let you know if that changes."
Gentle exit: "Thanks for the offer, but I'll pass for now. Good luck with your search!"
Platform notes
- Facebook Marketplace: confirm the exact price and pickup time in the chat before meeting, and meet in a public, well-lit place. If someone arrives with less cash than agreed, it's fine to politely decline.
- eBay: use Best Offer settings to auto-decline offers below your floor and auto-accept ones above a set amount. It saves a lot of messages.
- Poshmark: many buyers expect to make an offer, so some sellers list a little above their target. Countering is normal and expected.
- Mercari: offers are common; countering once with a fair number usually works. See Mercari vs Poshmark fees to know your real take-home.
When to counter and when to walk away
Counter when the buyer seems genuine: they ask about condition, measurements or pickup, and the offer is in the neighborhood of your floor. Walk away when the offer is far below your floor, the buyer only talks price, or they keep pushing after a polite no. You never owe an explanation, and a calm "no thanks" protects your time for real buyers.
Prevent lowballs in the first place
- Show the value. Clear photos, brand, size, measurements and honest condition notes help buyers see why the price makes sense.
- Price with a specific number. $58 can look more considered than $60.
- Mention comps in the description when appropriate, such as "priced below recent sold listings."
- Say what you'll consider. "Reasonable offers welcome" invites fair offers; "Price is firm" discourages haggling.
If every offer is low
If you only ever get lowball offers, the market may be telling you something. Recheck sold comps, compare your photos and title to listings that sold quickly, and consider a small price drop. Our guides on pricing thrift flips with AI and AI prompts for eBay titles can help you spot the gap.
Buyer messages in seconds
The AI Reseller Flip Kit includes 35 copy-paste prompts for comps, titles, descriptions, pricing and buyer messages, including polite replies to offers, plus a condition grading key and profit formula. $5. Not affiliated with any marketplace; no income guarantees.
FAQ
How do you politely respond to a lowball offer? Thank the buyer, say you can't go that low, and give a specific counter, such as 'The lowest I can do is $52 for pickup today.'
Should I ignore lowball offers? For offers far below your floor, a short polite no or no reply is fine. For offers within about 20 to 30 percent of your price, a counter often leads to a sale.
How do I stop getting lowball offers? Show the value with clear photos, measurements and honest condition notes, price with a specific number, and say whether you accept offers.
What should I say when a buyer asks for my lowest price? Ask them to make an offer first, for example: 'I'm open to reasonable offers. What did you have in mind?'